The Ohio Statehouse in Columbus, with flags on its roof

Form 990-PFTax year 2025EIN 31-1550874

The Wm M & A Cafaro Family Foundation

A private foundation in Niles, OH. Its return for tax year 2025 lists 377 grants and $1.7 million paid in grants.

Tax year 2025 (period ending Mar 31, 2026), read from the IRS e-file on Nov 11, 2026. Returns reach the IRS 5 to 18 months after the year they describe.

How to apply

Accepts applications

The return gives an application contact and rules, as below.

Contact person
On file
Phone
On file
Mailing address
On file
Form and materials
On file
Deadlines
None
Restrictions
None

Contact person, phone, mailing address and application materials on file. See them with a plan.

Assets and giving by year

6 returns on file
Grants paid by tax year. The latest year is in blue.
  • Tax year 2025

    $1,739,831

    Grants listed
    377
    Assets, end of year
    $23,263,994
  • Tax year 2024

    $1,422,621

    Grants listed
    432
    Assets, end of year
    $25,003,825
  • Tax year 2023

    $1,675,948

    Grants listed
    362
    Assets, end of year
    $24,528,456
  • Tax year 2022

    $1,844,869

    Grants listed
    396
    Assets, end of year
    $25,718,642
  • Tax year 2021

    $1,629,877

    Grants listed
    338
    Assets, end of year
    $26,829,759
  • Tax year 2020

    $1,519,770

    Grants listed
    282
    Assets, end of year
    $26,399,747

Grants paid in 2025

377 grants, largest first

As listed on the return.

  1. Youngstown State UniversityYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $300,000
  2. JFK Catholic High SchoolWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $100,000
  3. JFK Catholic High SchoolWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $100,000
  4. Vienna TownshipVienna, OH

    General purpose

    $100,000
  5. Lake to River FoundationYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $50,000
  6. United Way of Trumbull CountyWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $50,000
  7. Vienna TownshipVienna, OH

    General purpose

    $50,000
  8. Youngstown State UniversityYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $31,000
  9. Youngstown Warren Regional Chamber of Commerce FoundationYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $30,000
  10. Youngstownwarren Regional Chamber of Commerce FoundationYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $30,000
  11. Kennedy Catholic Family of SchoolsHermitage, PA

    General purpose

    $25,000
  12. Neomed FoundationRootstown, OH

    General purpose

    $25,000
  13. Neomed FoundationRootstown, OH

    General purpose

    $25,000
  14. Oblate Sisters of the Sacred Heart of JesusHubbard, OH

    General purpose

    $25,000
  15. Oblate Sisters of the Sacred Heart of JesusHubbard, OH

    General purpose

    $25,000
  16. Our Lady of Mount Carmel BasilicaYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $20,000
  17. Totes of AppreciationHudson, OH

    General purpose

    $20,000
  18. Northeastern Educational Television of OhioKent, OH

    General purpose

    $17,000
  19. Ohio State UniversityColumbus, OH

    General purpose

    $17,000
  20. Kearsarge Fire DepartmentErie, PA

    General purpose

    $15,000
  21. Kent State UniversityKent, OH

    General purpose

    $15,000
  22. Pitch in Charitable FoundationNiles, OH

    General purpose

    $15,000
  23. The Penguin ClubYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $15,000
  24. Foundation MediciWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $11,500
  25. Foundation MediciWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $11,500
  26. Akron Children's Hospital of the Mahoning ValleyBoardman, OH

    General purpose

    $10,000
  27. Austintown Local School DistrictAustintown, OH

    General purpose

    $10,000
  28. Barnesville Shamrock 200 ClubBarnesville, OH

    General purpose

    $10,000
  29. Bridgeport High SchoolBridgeport, WV

    General purpose

    $10,000
  30. Central Catholic High SchoolWheeling, WV

    General purpose

    $10,000
  31. Central Catholic High SchoolWheeling, WV

    General purpose

    $10,000
  32. Central Catholic High SchoolWheeling, WV

    General purpose

    $10,000
  33. Coleman Professional ServicesKent, OH

    General purpose

    $10,000
  34. Girard High SchoolGirard, OH

    General purpose

    $10,000
  35. JFK Catholic High SchoolWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $10,000
  36. Marshall County SchoolsMoundsville, WV

    General purpose

    $10,000
  37. Marshall County SchoolsMoundsville, WV

    General purpose

    $10,000
  38. McDonald Local School DistrictMcDonald, OH

    General purpose

    $10,000
  39. McDonald VillageMcDonald, OH

    General purpose

    $10,000
  40. Millcreek Township School DistrictErie, PA

    General purpose

    $10,000
  41. Second Harvest Food BankYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $10,000
  42. Switzerland of Ohio Local School DistrictWoodsfield, OH

    General purpose

    $10,000
  43. Valley Economic Development Partners IncYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $10,000
  44. West Middlesex School DistrictWest Middlesex, PA

    General purpose

    $10,000
  45. Wheeling Park High SchoolWheeling, WV

    General purpose

    $10,000
  46. YWCA Mahoning ValleyYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $10,000
  47. Alex's Lemonade Stand FoundationWynnewood, PA

    General purpose

    $7,921
  48. Lake Erie College of Osteopathic MedicineErie, PA

    General purpose

    $7,500
  49. Our Lady of Mount Carmel BasilicaYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $7,500
  50. St Rose Catholic ChurchGirard, OH

    General purpose

    $7,500
  51. Oblate Sisters of the Sacred Heart of JesusHubbard, OH

    General purpose

    $7,000
  52. Walsh UniversityN Canton, OH

    General purpose

    $7,000
  53. Westminster CollegeNew Wilmngtn, PA

    General purpose

    $7,000
  54. Bowling Green UniversityBowling Green, OH

    General purpose

    $6,000
  55. Akron Children's Hospital of the Mahoning ValleyYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  56. Animal Charity of Ohio IncBoardman, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  57. Crohn's & Colitis FoundationNew York, NY

    General purpose

    $5,000
  58. Down Syndrome Association of the ValleyBoardman, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  59. Edward J Debartolo Memorial Scholarship FoundationYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  60. Fairhaven FoundationNiles, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  61. Grace Fellowship ChurchNiles, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  62. Kent State University FoundationKent, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  63. Metro Erie Meals on WheelsErie, PA

    General purpose

    $5,000
  64. Miami UniversityOxford, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  65. Niles McKinley High SchoolNiles, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  66. Niles McKinley High SchoolNiles, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  67. Ohio UniversityAthens, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  68. Our Lady of Mount Carmel BasilicaYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  69. Our Lady of Mount Carmel BasilicaYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  70. Second Harvest Food BankYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  71. Sight for All UnitedStruthers, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  72. St Rose Catholic ChurchGirard, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  73. St Rose Catholic ChurchGirard, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  74. St Rose Catholic ChurchGirard, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  75. The Everybody OrganizationBoardman, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  76. The Penguin Club Youngstown State UniversityYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  77. Thrive Mahoning ValleyYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  78. Totes of AppreciationHudson, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  79. United Way of the River Cities IncHuntington, WV

    General purpose

    $5,000
  80. University of ToledoToledo, OH

    General purpose

    $5,000
  81. Cleveland State UniversityCleveland, OH

    General purpose

    $4,000
  82. University of CincinnatiCincinnati, OH

    General purpose

    $4,000
  83. Youngstown State UniversityYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $4,000
  84. Capital UniversityColumbus, OH

    General purpose

    $3,000
  85. Carnegie Mellon UniversityPittsburgh, PA

    General purpose

    $3,000
  86. Mercyhurst UniversityErie, PA

    General purpose

    $3,000
  87. Ohio Wesleyan UniversityDelaware, OH

    General purpose

    $3,000
  88. Seton Hill UniversityGreensburg, PA

    General purpose

    $3,000
  89. American Cancer SocietyCleveland, OH

    General purpose

    $2,750
  90. United Way of Trumbull CountyWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $2,750
  91. Austintown Generational Enrichment CorpAustintown, OH

    General purpose

    $2,500
  92. Axess Family Services IncWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $2,500
  93. Catholic CharitiesYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $2,500
  94. Catholic CharitiesYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $2,500
  95. Game Changers Leadership & Peer Mentoring InitiativeWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $2,500
  96. JFK Catholic High SchoolWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $2,500
  97. Lordstown Local SchoolsWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $2,500
  98. Newton Falls High SchoolNewton Falls, OH

    General purpose

    $2,500
  99. Our Lady of Mount Carmel BasilicaYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $2,500
  100. Pink Lights the WayWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $2,500
  101. Rust City ChurchNiles, OH

    General purpose

    $2,500
  102. Youngstown Edison Incubator CorporationYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $2,500
  103. Austin Peay State UniversityClarksburg, TN

    General purpose

    $2,000
  104. Denison UniversityGranville, OH

    General purpose

    $2,000
  105. John Carroll UniversityUniversity HT, OH

    General purpose

    $2,000
  106. Niles Community ServicesNiles, OH

    General purpose

    $2,000
  107. Ohio Northern UniversityAda, OH

    General purpose

    $2,000
  108. Slippery Rock UniversitySlippery Rock, PA

    General purpose

    $2,000
  109. St Maron Church - MyoYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $2,000
  110. United States Merchant Marine AcademyKings Point, NY

    General purpose

    $2,000
  111. Ursuline High SchoolYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $2,000
  112. Public Broadcasting of Northwest Pennsylvania IncErie, PA

    General purpose

    $1,800
  113. Youngstown State UniversityYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $1,750
  114. Big Blue Football ClubPuyallup, WA

    General purpose

    $1,500
  115. Community Foundation of Western PA & Eastern OhioWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $1,500
  116. Community Foundation of Western PA & Eastern OhioWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $1,500
  117. St Rose SchoolGirard, OH

    General purpose

    $1,500
  118. Alzheimer's Disease & Related Disorders Association IncChicago, IL

    General purpose

    $1,000
  119. American Heart AssociationDallas, TX

    General purpose

    $1,000
  120. Buffalo Soldiers Motorcycle ClubCairo, IL

    General purpose

    $1,000
  121. Cardinal Mooney High SchoolYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  122. Check A Vet IncMurray, KY

    General purpose

    $1,000
  123. Community Foundation of Monroe CountyMonroe, MI

    General purpose

    $1,000
  124. Community Foundation of Western PA & Eastern OhioHermitage, PA

    General purpose

    $1,000
  125. Fort Campbell Spouses ClubFort Campbell, KY

    General purpose

    $1,000
  126. GFWC Warren Junior Women's LeagueCortland, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  127. Hamot Health FoundationErie, PA

    General purpose

    $1,000
  128. Howland Schools PTOWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  129. Kennedy Catholic Family of SchoolsHermitage, PA

    General purpose

    $1,000
  130. Lakeview Little BulldogsCortland, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  131. Lids FoundationIndianapolis, IN

    General purpose

    $1,000
  132. Loaves & FishesClarksville, TN

    General purpose

    $1,000
  133. Lordstown Police AssociationWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  134. Manna Caf MinistriesClarksville, TN

    General purpose

    $1,000
  135. Market House Theatre of Paducah KentuckyPaducah, KY

    General purpose

    $1,000
  136. Mercy Health Foundation Mahoning ValleyBoardman, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  137. Monroe County Fair AssociationMonroe, MI

    General purpose

    $1,000
  138. Oblate Sisters of the Sacred Heart of JesusHubbard, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  139. Oblate Sisters of the Sacred Heart of JesusHubbard, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  140. Oblate Sisters of the Sacred Heart of JesusHubbard, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  141. Partners Advocating & Working for StudentsWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  142. Puyallup Valley St Francis HousePuyallup, WA

    General purpose

    $1,000
  143. River Raisin Centre for the ArtsMonroe, MI

    General purpose

    $1,000
  144. St Edward ParishYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  145. St Clairsville Band ParentsSt Clairsville, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  146. St Edward ParishYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  147. St Edward ParishYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  148. The HWWC Medal of Honor Education Foundation IncLouisville, KY

    General purpose

    $1,000
  149. Trumbull County Afro American Achievers AssociationWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  150. Warren Civic Music AssociationWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  151. Warren Family MissionWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  152. Warren Gridiron ClubWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  153. Weathersfield Local School DistrictMineral Ridge, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  154. Youngstown Area Jewish FederationYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $1,000
  155. Lakeview Local SchoolsCortland, OH

    General purpose

    $750
  156. Christian Youth Theatre FredericksburgFredericksburg, VA

    General purpose

    $600
  157. Girard Robotics Booster ClubGirard, OH

    General purpose

    $600
  158. Dubuque Arboretum AssociationDubuque, IA

    General purpose

    $523
  159. Ability Works IncSandusky, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  160. All Things Fun SportsSumner, WA

    General purpose

    $500
  161. Association for Needy & Neglected AnimalsErie, PA

    General purpose

    $500
  162. Association of Fundraising ProfessionalsYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  163. Autism Society of Mahoning ValleyYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  164. Autism Society of Mahoning ValleyYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  165. Back to the WildCastalia, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  166. Bags of Love Wky IncBenton, KY

    General purpose

    $500
  167. Because You Care IncMC Kean, PA

    General purpose

    $500
  168. Belmont County Cat Stray Shun ProgramMorristown, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  169. Bess Purpose IncStruthers, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  170. Blood AssuranceChattanooga, TN

    General purpose

    $500
  171. Bobbies Pit Bull Rescue & Sanctuary IncSpotsylvania, VA

    General purpose

    $500
  172. Boys & Girls Club of Greater DubuqueDubuque, IA

    General purpose

    $500
  173. Brouillet Elementary PTAPuyallup, WA

    General purpose

    $500
  174. Buckhannon Upshur High SchoolBuckhannon, WV

    General purpose

    $500
  175. Cabell Wayne Association of the BlindHuntington, WV

    General purpose

    $500
  176. Cadence Care NetworkNiles, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  177. Canine CrusadersGirard, PA

    General purpose

    $500
  178. Catholic Charities West VirginiaWheeling, WV

    General purpose

    $500
  179. Champion Robotics BoostersWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  180. Child Advocacy Network of Monroe CountyMonroe, MI

    General purpose

    $500
  181. Civitan International FBO St Bethlehem Civitan ClubBirmingham, AL

    General purpose

    $500
  182. Clarksburgh League of Service IncClarksburg, WV

    General purpose

    $500
  183. Clarksburgh MissionsClarksburg, WV

    General purpose

    $500
  184. Clarksville Montgomery County Crime Stoppers IncClarksville, TN

    General purpose

    $500
  185. Cleveland Clinic FoundationSandusky, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  186. Clyde Public LibraryClyde, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  187. Community Cornerstone ProjectErie, PA

    General purpose

    $500
  188. Community FND of Western PA & Eastern OhioSharon, PA

    General purpose

    $500
  189. Community Foundation of Western PA & Eastern OhioWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  190. Cooking Autism IncAlexandria, VA

    General purpose

    $500
  191. Crocus FoundationDubuque, IA

    General purpose

    $500
  192. Cystic Fibrosis FoundationValley View, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  193. Developmental Therapy Center IncHuntington, WV

    General purpose

    $500
  194. Downtown GreensFredericksbrg, VA

    General purpose

    $500
  195. Dress for Success Warren-YoungstownWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  196. Dubuque County Historical SocietyDubuque, IA

    General purpose

    $500
  197. Dubuque Dream CenterDubuque, IA

    General purpose

    $500
  198. Dubuque Food PantryDubuque, IA

    General purpose

    $500
  199. Dubuque Symphony OrchestraDubuque, IA

    General purpose

    $500
  200. English CenterYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  201. Fairy Godmother ProjectFredericksbrg, VA

    General purpose

    $500
  202. Family Service Society IncPaducah, KY

    General purpose

    $500
  203. Fitch Cheerleading BoosterYoungstown, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  204. Forever Moriah FoundationFredericksburg, VA

    General purpose

    $500
  205. Foundation for Dubuque Public SchoolsDubuque, IA

    General purpose

    $500
  206. Friends of 913Akron, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  207. Friends of Old Woman Creek AssociationHuron, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  208. Friends of St MarysDubuque, IA

    General purpose

    $500
  209. Gabby's Ladder IncMonroe, MI

    General purpose

    $500
  210. Gethsemane Full Gospel ChurchClarksville, TN

    General purpose

    $500
  211. GFWC Clarksville Women's ClubClarksville, TN

    General purpose

    $500
  212. Girard City SchoolsGirard, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  213. Girard Mulit-Generational CenterGirard, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  214. Glenville State UniversityGlenville, WV

    General purpose

    $500
  215. Grace African Methodist Episcopal ChurchWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  216. Grace Community ChurchSandusky, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  217. GreentrikeTacoma, WA

    General purpose

    $500
  218. Gwyneth's Gift Foundation IncFredericksburg, VA

    General purpose

    $500
  219. Harmony House IncWheeling, WV

    General purpose

    $500
  220. Heartbeat of SanduskySandusky, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  221. Helping Hand HousePuyallup, WA

    General purpose

    $500
  222. Historic Clarksburg WV Cemetery Preservation AllianceClarksburg, WV

    General purpose

    $500
  223. Hospice of DubuqueDubuque, IA

    General purpose

    $500
  224. Hubbard School Band SponsorsHubbard, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  225. Humane Society of Harrison County IncClarksburg, WV

    General purpose

    $500
  226. Huntington Children's Museum IncHuntington, WV

    General purpose

    $500
  227. Jackson Milton Local SchoolsNorth Jackson, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  228. James and Derek Hotsinpiller Memorial Scholarship FundBridgeport, WV

    General purpose

    $500
  229. Jefferson High SchoolNewport, MI

    General purpose

    $500
  230. John F Kennedy Catholic School - Warren JFK Boys Golf TeamWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  231. Joy Doll Hospital IncStafford, VA

    General purpose

    $500
  232. Junior League of Wheeling IncWheeling, WV

    General purpose

    $500
  233. Lakeshore Community Services IncErie, PA

    General purpose

    $500
  234. Libertas InstituteLehi, UT

    General purpose

    $500
  235. Limitless Dance CompanyBoardman, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  236. Local PositivityFredericksbrg, VA

    General purpose

    $500
  237. Logan's Landing ProjectCortland, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  238. Logan's Landing ProjectCortland, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  239. Marine Toys for Tots FoundationTriangle, VA

    General purpose

    $500
  240. Mathews Rebounders ClubVienna, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  241. McCracken County Humane SocietyPaducah, KY

    General purpose

    $500
  242. Melanie Kirk StauffersSequim, WA

    General purpose

    $500
  243. Monroe County Business AllianceMonroe, MI

    General purpose

    $500
  244. Monroe County Intermediate School DistrictMonroe, MI

    General purpose

    $500
  245. Monroe County Opportunity ProgramMonroe, MI

    General purpose

    $500
  246. Montgomery County Soccer Association IncClarksville, TN

    General purpose

    $500
  247. Mountwest Foundation IncHuntington, WV

    General purpose

    $500
  248. MS IncClarksburg, WV

    General purpose

    $500
  249. National Association of the WolvesWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $500
  250. Ne Ohio St Vincent de Paul Diocesan Council IncWarren, OH

    General purpose

    $500

Where the money goes

By cause: grants to organizations we matched to the IRS list of exempt organizations, by their category.

  1. Education32 grants $112,25024% of the total
  2. Philanthropy and grantmaking14 grants $97,50021% of the total
  3. Community development11 grants $95,85021% of the total
  4. Health19 grants $25,6006% of the total
  5. Arts and culture13 grants $24,3775% of the total
  6. Human services24 grants $23,5005% of the total
  7. 13 other causes55 grants $81,87318% of the total

By State

Grants to organizations with a US address, latest year.

  1. Ohio223 grants $1,488,060
  2. Pennsylvania34 grants $111,021
  3. West Virginia45 grants $92,750
  4. Virginia15 grants $8,000
  5. Iowa15 grants $7,500
  6. Michigan12 grants $7,500
  7. Washington12 grants $7,500
  8. Tennessee8 grants $6,500
  9. Kentucky8 grants $6,000
  10. New York1 grant $2,000

Officers, directors and trustees

3 people as filed

As filed on the return, with average hours per week and pay from the foundation.

  • Anthony M CafaroTRUSTEE Hours 5Pay $0
  • Capri S CafaroTRUSTEE Hours 5Pay $0
  • William A CafaroTRUSTEE Hours 5Pay $0

The return

More foundations

Similar foundations

Same main cause (education), giving between a quarter and four times this foundation’s where possible, nearby first.

  1. The S L Hickman Family FoundationShaker Heights, OH 13 grants Accepts applications $1,779,041 giving
  2. Jerome T Osborne and Georgeanne S Osborne Charitable TrustMentor, OH 54 grants Preselected only $1,651,000 giving
  3. The Charles L Shor Foundation IncCincinnati, OH 24 grants Preselected only $1,645,637 giving
  4. Joan C Edwards Charitable FoundationDefiance, OH 3 grants Preselected only $1,889,553 giving
  5. Stanard Family FoundationCleveland, OH 4 grants Preselected only $1,575,000 giving